Wolfram Alpha is amazing, but it has a fundamental flaw.

Wolfram Alpha is amazing. Go play with it now.

Some people really, really don't get it. They are frustrated that it isn't google, which of course it was never meant to be. If you're not sure what it is then I recommend the (overlong) intro video.

But basically, It's a data engine. A fact machine. It lets you pull and push and manipulate data.

For instance you could compare the mean wage of chiropractors vs journalists in seconds (topical!). Or do some maths. Or do lots of things.

It's some topical data about two professions.

And this is all the info your are given for your 'source'

It's finicky and has plenty of holes in it, but it's only just gone live and it is brilliant. I can't stress that enough.

Now on to why it sucks.

The cultural effects of a 'computational knowledge engine' that can both quantify and manipulate data is huge. But the ability for it to be misused is also huge. We all love wikipeida, but when journalists use it for their primary source of info it gets a little worrying. To offset that Wikipedia has a big list of references at the bottom of every page.

Rather than establish itself as an authority figure (despite the wishes of some of the more 'enthusiastic' admins) Wikipedia works hard to tell you how it knows something to be true, otherwise [citation needed] rears its head.

I don't get that same feeling from Wolfram Alpha. Firstly, the references are tucked away from view in a little pop up window rather than being an inherent part of the page. Secondly, the Primary source for everything I've tried so far is:

Wolfram|Alpha curated data, 2009

Which just isn't good enough. It is setting Alpha up to be an authority figure for data. But this isn't information that Wolfram et al. have discovered and published. This is information that Wolfram has collated.

Now, to be fair, 'background' sources are listed. And whilst they are most likely the true source of the data presented, no single study or report or finding is indicated to be where any specific fact came from. For example Alpha has decided that the UK produces 1.8 billion barrels of oil a day. Has it taken an average of the studies it looked at? Or has it weighted them? It doesn't tell me.

Every piece of data when fed into Alpha should have been tagged with details of where it came from. But it isn't. It's a mind boggling strange omission.

So much so that I can't help but feel this, may possibly, add weight to widespread opinion that Stephen Wolfram is a little bit, erm, arrogant. This letter that Richard Feynman (apparently) wrote to Stephen Wolfram is rather illuminating on the subject. The cynic in me whispers that Alpha wants to be your reference, not your intermediary.

Wolfram|Alpha is an amazing achievement, and one I will use an awful lot. (even if it is just to plot nonsense) Stephen Wolfram should be immensely proud of it.

But I can't help thinking how much more important Alpha would be as a proper research tool if it was a little bit more willing to explain where it learnt to be so clever.


Anonymous said...

Where you've written "admission" (4th paragraph from bottom), should that read "omission"?

Bill said...

Cheers! Fixed the typo.

I'm sure there are plenty more.

Upa said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Upa said...

Lacking the references is of course a flaw.

Another one is that WolframAlpha will always have out-of-date information by design. It collects data from some external sources and tries to turn these data into something more complicated that just inverted index (as in Google case). This takes time and needs always be adjusted to changing formats of sources. In two words - will never work real-time.

HJ said...

That's 5 words.

Lave said...

I don't think anyone cares about it not working real time. Collating data in a way that allows it to be manipulated takes time, but allows you to do far more with it than you can otherwise.

Jhon said...

This takes time and needs always be adjusted to changing formats of sources.

You cannot go wrong on the best security systems

Lin Huang said...

michael kors outlet online
kobe shoes
michael kors outlet
michael kors outlet
jordan 11s
michael kors outlet online sale
jordan concords
jordan 3
football jerseys
michael kors outlet
oakley sunglasses outlet
lebron james shoes
christian louboutin
true religion
michael kors
ralph lauren outlet
michael kors outlet online
michael kors outlet
hollister clothing
coach outlet
hollister co
michael kors handbags
hollister outlet
abercrombie store
louis vuitton outlet
kate spade outlet
louis vuitton outlet
toms shoes
burberry outlet online
louis vuitton outlet stores
oakley sunglasses wholesale
coach factory outlet
abercrombie & fitch
polo ralph lauren
michael kors outlet
louis vuitton

Wenhao Guo said...

new orleans saints jerseys
ralph lauren uk
nike air max uk
toms shoes
soccer jerseys
michael kors handbags
coach outlet canada
vans shoes
cheap mlb jerseys
michael kors uk
real madrid jersey
swarovski jewelry
atlanta falcons jersey
tory burch outlet online
louis vuitton uk
dallas cowboys jersey
the north face clearance
cheap nike shoes
fred perry sale
marc jacobs outlet
true religion jeans
true religion jeans
ray ban sunglasses
burberry outlet online, http://www.burberryoutletonlinestore.com.co
mcm bags
burberry outlet
oakley sunglasses
ray ban wayfarer
true religion jeans, http://www.truereligionjeansoutlet.com
vibram fivefingers
lacoste polo shirts
minnesota vikings jerseys
nike free 5.0
new york giants jerseys
kate spade outlet
true religion outlet, http://www.truereligionoutletstore.us.com
dansko outlet
cheap jordans
kate spade outlet
herve leger

chenlina said...

louis vuitton handbags
nike roshe run
nike roshe runs
ray ban sunglasses
ray ban sunglass
louis vuitton
mont blanc
kate spade handbags
michael kors handbags
new jordans
ray-ban aviator
michael kors bag
cheap jerseys
ray ban glasses
michael kors outlet
nike trainers
michael kors handbags
michael kors outlet online
uggs on sale
aviator sunglasses
louis vuitton outlet
fitflops sale
tods outlet
coach handags
nike huarache white
cheap air max
louis vuitton handbags
michael kors outlet online
michael kors handbags
ray ban glasses
louis vuitton handbags
louis vuitton outlet
mcm outlet
jordan 4 toro
tory burch flats
gucci shoes
coach factorty outlet
jordan retro 4

驴小布 said...

20151104 junda
nike uk
mulberry bags
ray ban
michael kors outlet online
kate spade handbags
hermes belt
jordan retro 3
true religion outlet
coach outlet
nike air max uk
ugg boots
adidas trainers
michael kors outlet
nike air jordan
nike outlet
hollister uk
michael kors
new balance outlet
ugg boots
michael kors handbags
mont blanc pens
toms outlet store
cheap oakley sunglasses
longchamp outlet
louis vuitton outlet
louis vuitton handbags
canada gooses outlet
adidas superstars
ray ban sunglasses
pandora jewelry
gucci borse
ed hardy outlet
michael kors
coach factory outlet
juicy couture
michael kors handbags
toms outlet
gucci outlet
coach outlet
louis vuitton